Replies to our Critics
نویسندگان
چکیده
We are grateful to José Bermúdez and to Andrea Cristiano Pierno, Caterina Ansuini and Umberto Castiello for reading and criticizing our book. They offer us an opportunity to clarify some of our views. Bermúdez discusses aspects of our version of the two-visual systems model of human vision bearing on the separation between the content of visuomotor representations and the content of visual percepts. Pierno, Ansuini and Castiello discuss our interpretation of the contribution of mirror neurons to the content of an observer’s representation of an agent’s intentions. In accordance with the structure of our book, we shall discuss these issues in this order.
منابع مشابه
Adequacy of authors’ replies to criticism raised in electronic letters to the editor: cohort study
OBJECTIVE To investigate whether substantive criticism in electronic letters to the editor, defined as a problem that could invalidate the research or reduce its reliability, is adequately addressed by the authors. DESIGN Cohort study. SETTING BMJ between October 2005 and September 2007. Inclusion criteria Research papers generating substantive criticism in the rapid responses section on bm...
متن کاملReplies to My Critics
I thank my critics for time, thought, and effort put into their commentaries. Since obviously I can’t respond to everything, I will try to address what strike me as the most important questions they ask and objections they raise. I think I have decent answers to some questions and decent responses to some objections, in other cases it seems enough to clarify the relevant view, and in still othe...
متن کاملPersonal Identity and Practical Reason: The Failure of Kantian Replies to Parfit
This essay examines and criticizes a set of Kantian objections to Parfit’s attempt in Reasons and Persons to connect his theory of personal identity to practical rationality and moral philosophy. Several of Parfit’s critics have tried to sever the link he forges between his metaphysical and practical conclusions by invoking the Kantian thought that even if we accept his metaphysical theory of p...
متن کاملInteractive comment on “Seasonal predictability of the winter precipitation over Iberian Peninsula and its relationship with finite-time Lyapunov exponents” by Daniel Garaboa-Paz et al
We would like to thank the Referee for his/her valuable comments and critics that we tried to take into account in the revised version of the manuscript. Hopefully, all the major and minor corrections pointed out by the reviewer have been corrected now. A detailed answer follows below. We provide replies to the reviewer’ comments in bold. As well, corrections included in the manuscript are mark...
متن کاملSelective deficits in human audition: evidence from lesion studies
The human auditory cortex is the gateway to the most powerful and complex communication systems and yet relatively little is known about its functional organization as compared to the visual system. Several lines of evidence, predominantly from recent studies, indicate that sound recognition and sound localization are processed in two at least partially independent networks. Evidence from human...
متن کامل